The Ferocity of U.S. Criminal Justice

Towards the end of a criminal trial in which a law partner of mine was defense counsel, he was approached by a journalist from a German newspaper who had been observing the trial. She asked him why American criminal justice was so ferocious towards defendants. The question is a good one. Our system is, in fact, anti-defendant to a degree perhaps unique in the civilized world. The German journalist’s question highlights a great divide in perception, for if you raised the subject of criminal justice with a random citizen of the United States, the question you might hear would be: “When are the courts going to close the loopholes and stop being revolving doors for criminals?”

The Fifth Amendment Does Not Entail the Constitutionality of Capital Punishment

The Fifth Amendment of the US Constitution anticipates the existence of capital punishment. Justice Scalia declared that it follows that capital punishment is constitutional. He was wrong.