Friday, February 13, 2015

Normative Words in the Constitution: Capital Punishment and Due Process

Some constitutional interpreters, including some who regularly put on robes, argue that capital punishment must be constitutional under the Eighth Amendment  because nearly all the drafters, and the great majority of the ratifiers, would not have thought it "cruel and unusual." This reasoning is exactly as sound as that producing the conclusion that there would be no Fifth Amendment  "due process of law" objection to restricting the jury to white males in trying a criminal action against a female African American.